How in the world is this a Geometry question? I don't know but it's freaking confusing!!!! HELP!!!!!!!!!!!

Question

anonymous · Answer

Which of these is a valid conclusion?
Answer
		
All carpenters make furniture.  
   Patrick makes furniture.
   Therefore Patrick is a carpenter.
		
All carpenters make furniture.  
       Patrick does not make furniture.
       Therefore Patrick is not a carpenter.
		
All carpenters make furniture.  
   Patrick is not a carpenter.
   Therefore Patrick makes furniture.
		
All carpenters make furniture.  
   Patrick is a carpenter.
   Therefore Patrick does not make furniture.

anonymous · Answer

well, the last two dont make sense whatsoever. 

Basically, if a=b and b=c then a=c right? makes sense?

So it has to be one of the first two.  can you figure out which one it is?

anonymous · Answer

I narrowed it down between those two

anonymous · Answer

already

anonymous · Answer

I put the first one

anonymous · Answer

But I think it could be the second one too

anonymous · Answer

but still confused?

anonymous · Answer

yeah how could it be two answers?

anonymous · Answer

the first one is weird. I think that just because he makes furniture doesn't mean he's a carpenter, but carpenters have to make furniture. see what i mean?

so all carpenter make furniture. 

it didnt say that if you make furniture you are are carpenter. 

see what i mean?

anonymous · Answer

OMG confusing but ok

anonymous · Answer

I get it

anonymous · Answer

alright:D so now you get to choose.

anonymous · Answer

Thanks

anonymous · Answer

pleasure.