Which of these is a valid conclusion?

All carpenters make furniture.
Patrick is a carpenter.
Therefore Patrick does not make furniture.

All carpenters make furniture.
Patrick is not a carpenter.
Therefore Patrick makes furniture.

All carpenters make furniture.
Patrick makes furniture.
Therefore Patrick is a carpenter.

All carpenters make furniture.
Patrick does not make furniture.
Therefore Patrick is not a carpenter.

Question

Which of these is a valid conclusion?

 All carpenters make furniture.   
Patrick is a carpenter. 
Therefore Patrick does not make furniture.

 All carpenters make furniture.   
Patrick is not a carpenter. 
Therefore Patrick makes furniture.

 All carpenters make furniture.   
Patrick makes furniture. 
Therefore Patrick is a carpenter.

 All carpenters make furniture.   
Patrick does not make furniture. 
Therefore Patrick is not a carpenter.

anonymous · Answer

@blurbendy @Loser66 @Preetha @whpalmer4 @Luigi0210 @Loser66 @yoda5657

anonymous · Answer

best answer gets a medal

anonymous · Answer

@Luigi0210 @ZakaullahUET @Compassionate @vinnv226 @bahrom7893 @NoelGreco

anonymous · Answer

@NickRockz @iluvreading @mathslover @GreenBeanDemphsey

anonymous · Answer

All carpenters make furniture.   
Patrick does not make furniture. 
Therefore Patrick is not a carpenter.

anonymous · Answer

Please help Best answer gets fan and medal

blurbendy · Answer

the last one is logical and makes sense

anonymous · Answer

@blurbendy do you agree

compassionate · Answer

All carpenters make furniture, 
Patrick makes furniture, but not all people who make furniture are carpenters. 

Look at question D/

anonymous · Answer

I agree that last one is most logical