Which of the following would be most likely ruled irrelevant in a murder case?

A. The accused and the victim had once dated the same woman.
B. The accused owned a gun like the one used to kill the victim.
C. The accused was suspended from school five years earlier for smoking cigarettes.
D. The accused had told several people that he did not like the victim.

Question

Which of the following would be most likely ruled irrelevant in a murder case? 



 A. The accused and the victim had once dated the same woman. 
 B. The accused owned a gun like the one used to kill the victim. 
 C. The accused was suspended from school five years earlier for smoking cigarettes. 
 D. The accused had told several people that he did not like the victim.

ipwnbunnies · Answer

My best guess is C...lol.

chris911 · Answer

lol

ipwnbunnies · Answer

A is a witness, B seems like evidence, D sorta seems like evidence. The suspect's past in school doesn't really matter I believe. It can cause suspicion, but it's not a basis to form a decision.

anonymous · Answer

C. The accused was suspended from school five years earlier for smoking cigarettes.