Which of these sentences contains an illogical comparison?

A.
Jake has collected more donations than Lindsay has collected.

B.
Our new patio cover gives us better shade than our old one.

C.
This puppy was the friendliest of all the puppies in the litter.

D.
His entry in the sandcastle competition is better than Megan.

Question

Which of these sentences contains an illogical comparison?	
 
 A.
Jake has collected more donations than Lindsay has collected.
 
 B.
Our new patio cover gives us better shade than our old one.
 
 C.
This puppy was the friendliest of all the puppies in the litter.
 
 D.
His entry in the sandcastle competition is better than Megan.

anonymous · Answer

C.
This puppy was the friendliest of all the puppies in the litter.

anonymous · Answer

D. His entry in the sandcastle competition is better than Megan.