Question

Give me an ethical counter example for me premises

Answer 1

The topic is whether or not to torture a terrorist who has intel for a bombing of a building, but there are no authorities and it it up to you.

Answer 2

1.) the terrorist will bomb a building, then he is acting on his belief

2.) the terrorist has his own belief, therefore you can not forcefully alter his belief
-----------------------------------------------------------
Conclusion.) thus it is not your right to torture the terrorist