Question

My sister Aliah is both a comic and smart.
Is this sentence correct?

Answer 1

No, you could say she's comical.

Answer 2

And you can say "My sister Aliah is both smart and comical" It would make more sense

Answer 3

Unless someone's sister is literally a comic, but I'm sure that probably wouldn't be true. I agree with @BriannaBear :)

Answer 4

Its was wrong but thank you for your help.