If killing people is wrong, then why do we kill people that kill people? [debate]

Question

dezlynnm1000 · Answer

idk

Astrid1 · Answer

Technically that's not always the case where we kill people because they killed someone. You'd have to have spent a long time killing people to be able to die for your sins.

axie · Answer

Im not saying that death penalty is the only way of dealing with murderers, but I feel that people should die on there own terms, not there own.

Astro · Answer

We want those people to suffer for what they did, and the death penalty is not very common , it is only common in scenarios where the murder tortures his victim

Gorillaz1002 · Answer

bc they think if u kill some one you should also be killed........but thats dumb bc  life is stressful and horrible and unfair ......so just let them live and be punished by living ....death is a blessing.

Astrid1 · Answer

Everyone should die on their own terms but life isn't always perfect.

And people have to face consequences for their actions.
People die, and shootings happen, it's not like we can make it stop. Because society won't always listen. They have their own opinions and we can't stop them.

Gorillaz1002 · Answer

@gorillaz1002 wrote:

bc they think if u kill some one you should also be killed........but thats dumb bc life is stressful and horrible and unfair ......so just let them live and be punished by living ....death is a blessing.

too much??

Joe348 · Answer

Because sometimes it is rite to kill someone because of all they kills they have that makes it justified

Joe348 · Answer

in my opinion cx

axie · Answer

@astro wrote:

We want those people to suffer for what they did, and the death penalty is not very common , it is only common in scenarios where the murder tortures his victim

Where im going with this, is it a technical extreme form of the golden rule? Do unto others as you want done unto you?

Gorillaz1002 · Answer

@joe348 wrote:

Because sometimes it is rite to kill someone because of all they kills they have that makes it justified

but then you would have to be killed

Gorillaz1002 · Answer

@gorillaz1002 wrote:

@joe348 wrote:

Because sometimes it is rite to kill someone because of all they kills they have that makes it justified

but then you would have to be killed

if u killed........nevermind im confused

Astro · Answer

@axie wrote:

@astro wrote:

We want those people to suffer for what they did, and the death penalty is not very common , it is only common in scenarios where the murder tortures his victim

Where im going with this, is it a technical extreme form of the golden rule? Do unto others as you want done unto you?

Well, There is reason to it so. There is two sides of the story but personally I think it is unfair to most extent, except those rare cases.

0mega · Answer

We killed Osama Bin Laden, soooo

Astro · Answer

@0mega wrote:

We killed Osama Bin Laden, soooo

What does that have to do with anything?

Joe348 · Answer

@gorillaz1002 wrote:

@joe348 wrote:

Because sometimes it is rite to kill someone because of all they kills they have that makes it justified

but then you would have to be killed

no bc im the judge who makes the decision and technically I didnt kill them the people inside ther jail did im just making the order

0mega · Answer

@astro wrote:

@0mega wrote:

We killed Osama Bin Laden, soooo

What does that have to do with anything?

Im not here to argue only putting my statement

Astro · Answer

@0mega wrote:

@astro wrote:

@0mega wrote:

We killed Osama Bin Laden, soooo

What does that have to do with anything?

Im not here to argue only putting my statement

I'm asking though..What does that have to do with it?

Gorillaz1002 · Answer

@joe348 wrote:

@gorillaz1002 wrote:

@joe348 wrote:

Because sometimes it is rite to kill someone because of all they kills they have that makes it justified

but then you would have to be killed

no bc im the judge who makes the decision and technically I didnt kill them the people inside ther jail did im just making the order

but u ordered it ...

Sock · Answer

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

axie · Answer

@astro wrote:

@axie wrote:

@astro wrote:

We want those people to suffer for what they did, and the death penalty is not very common , it is only common in scenarios where the murder tortures his victim

Where im going with this, is it a technical extreme form of the golden rule? Do unto others as you want done unto you?

Well, There is reason to it so. There is two sides of the story but personally I think it is unfair to most extent, except those rare cases.

Like @0mega said, I feel that death penalty is and should only be used for people who made others suffer more than usual amounts [per killer norms] such as terrorists and other things i dont care to get specific about.

Gorillaz1002 · Answer

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

i agree

Astro · Answer

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

What if it was your family who got killed, Then would you want that person to die?

Someoneee · Answer

Why does this debate have to be so dark? Lol.

Astro · Answer

@astro wrote:

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

What if it was your family who got killed, Then would you want that person to die?

Not saying it's right but, Just a fake scenario

Gorillaz1002 · Answer

@astro wrote:

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

What if it was your family who got killed, Then would you want that person to die?

yes but life is more punishing

Astro · Answer

@gorillaz1002 wrote:

@astro wrote:

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

What if it was your family who got killed, Then would you want that person to die?

yes but life is more punishing

How's that?

Astrid1 · Answer

Either way, some pay for their crimes in labor, jail, or death.

Astro · Answer

@astrid1 wrote:

Either way, some pay for their crimes in labor, jail, or death.

I agree

Astrid1 · Answer

We can't stop people from their habits. It's just socially awkward and you can't just tell them, "hey stop." Because it sure as hell wont do crap to the situation. They'll probably just kill u as well.

Gorillaz1002 · Answer

@astro wrote:

@gorillaz1002 wrote:

@astro wrote:

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

What if it was your family who got killed, Then would you want that person to die?

yes but life is more punishing

How's that?

bc life sucks and its hurtful,stressful and unfair ......if someone killed my family then i would want them to live life

axie · Answer

i personally think death penalty is the best way out after killing some one

Astro · Answer

@axie wrote:

i personally think death penalty is the best way out after killing some one

It's painless so I agree

axie · Answer

mhm

Astrid1 · Answer

I agree with that ^^

Astrid1 · Answer

The point is, as long as their facing their consequences and they learn from what they've done, the situation has been resolved for one.

Astro · Answer

@astrid1 wrote:

The point is, as long as their facing their consequences and they learn from what they've done, the situation has been resolved for one.

That is ultimately the best end result, Great debate everyone.

axie · Answer

That was more of a test question for future debates i want to do. Crowd sourcing if you will.

Sock · Answer

@astro wrote:

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

What if it was your family who got killed, Then would you want that person to die?

Honestly, if it was my family that was killed I'd rather the person be tortured than killed, mostly so they could spend their life in pain than just a few seconds.

Gorillaz1002 · Answer

@sock wrote:

@astro wrote:

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

What if it was your family who got killed, Then would you want that person to die?

Honestly, if it was my family that was killed I'd rather the person be tortured than killed, mostly so they could spend their life in pain than just a few seconds.

yes i agree

Astrid1 · Answer

I agree as well.

axie · Answer

@axie wrote:

That was more of a test question for future debates i want to do. Crowd sourcing if you will.

Astrid1 · Answer

Interesting.

Astro · Answer

@sock wrote:

@astro wrote:

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

What if it was your family who got killed, Then would you want that person to die?

Honestly, if it was my family that was killed I'd rather the person be tortured than killed, mostly so they could spend their life in pain than just a few seconds.

Agree to disagree

Sock · Answer

@astro wrote:

@sock wrote:

Ok :D

@astro wrote:

@sock wrote:

In my opinion, I don't feel as if anyone deserves the death penalty. Plus there could be a good possibility that the person might want to die than stay on this earth and be tortured for the rest of their life. Depending on how they kill the person it could take a good bit of time of pain but it beats having the rest of their life in pain.

What if it was your family who got killed, Then would you want that person to die?

Honestly, if it was my family that was killed I'd rather the person be tortured than killed, mostly so they could spend their life in pain than just a few seconds.

Agree to disagree

XxXNessalulbaddieXxX · Answer

we kill people because sometimes we get angry or cant control anger , some are just mentally unstable and cant control themseleved

XxXNessalulbaddieXxX · Answer

but if ur not mentally unstable most people know murder is illegal . lol

NeverAlone · Answer

Communism. That's my answer.

axie · Answer

Agreed, if you kill me we all get killed!