Margo thinks Patrick hates her dog. Every time he comes to her house, he doesn't pet her dog. Is Margo making a reasonable argument?

Yes, if he won't pet her dog that means he hates it
Yes, living proof is always the best evidence
No, she does not have enough evidence
No, maybe Patrick does not like any pets, even cats

Question

Margo thinks Patrick hates her dog. Every time he comes to her house, he doesn't pet her dog. Is Margo making a reasonable argument?

Yes, if he won't pet her dog that means he hates it
 Yes, living proof is always the best evidence
 No, she does not have enough evidence
 No, maybe Patrick does not like any pets, even cats

Gucchi · Answer

am i right with C?

Gucchi · Answer

D might also makes sense but idk @vocaloid

Vocaloid · Answer

your original intuition is correct. C is a better answer than D, because D is still missing the point, because there's no proof about Patrick disliking his dog or animals in general.

ShadowKid3 · Answer

I think C might be right because if he doesnt pet it that doesnt really mean he doesnt like it. hope this helped at all