Question

Which area of individual competence is most lacking in the following scenario?

A small group is trying to find a solution to an ongoing problem. One member presents a solution to the others. Afterwards, the other group members begin to analyze and critique his idea, but he quickly becomes defensive.

critical thinking
effective listening
assertion
productive conflict

Answer 1

Based on the scenario you described, it seems that the area of individual competence that is most lacking is assertion. Specifically, the member who presented the solution may be struggling to assert themselves in a constructive way when faced with criticism and analysis from others in the group. By becoming defensive, they may be hindering the group's ability to work together to find a solution to the ongoing problem. Encouraging the member to learn how to assert themselves in a productive way could help the group overcome this hurdle and make progress toward a solution.

Answer 2

@arieonna