Ask your own question, for FREE!
Mathematics 13 Online
OpenStudy (anonymous):

Question Of The Day.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Prove that 1 = 2 , 0 = 1 and 1 = 2. I need clever answers.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

not this one again D: algbebraic expressions is my final answer

OpenStudy (anonymous):

algebraic*

OpenStudy (anonymous):

All are requested to try. This is a puzzle question.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

O + 4 = 5. solve for ooh.

OpenStudy (callisto):

x = 2x Cross out x -> 1=2 :S

OpenStudy (lgbasallote):

Let a= b Then a^2 = ab a^2 + a^2 = a^2 + ab 2a^2 = a^2 + ab 2a^2 - 2ab = a^2 + ab - 2ab 2a^2 - 2ab = a^2 - ab 2(a^2 - ab) = a^2 - ab --------- ------- a^2 - ab a^2 - ab 2 = 1

OpenStudy (anonymous):

U can answer in so many ways. Try all.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

whoa...I'm keeping my bf

OpenStudy (anonymous):

x + x = 4x x(1+1) = 4x (1 + 1) = 4 2 = 4 1 = 2

OpenStudy (anonymous):

@lgbasallote answer is thrilling. I was searching for ur answer, LGBA!!!!! Now proceed and u can solve that 1=0 and also 0 = 2.

OpenStudy (lgbasallote):

it's actually a fallacy lol =)) dividing 0 by 0 is illegal :p

OpenStudy (anonymous):

@Aadarsh: This is not a puzzle, this is wrong mathematics. Finding the error would be some fun though.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Everything is possible in maths, lgba.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

dividing by 0 is a fantasy?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Its fun time guys and girls. Lets enjoy

OpenStudy (anonymous):

stuff just got real.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

aad plzz aye koi question hai ..........

OpenStudy (callisto):

@ffm true, we cannot cancel the variables like that :P

OpenStudy (apoorvk):

let x=0 then 20x = 100x or x = 5x or 1 = 5 :P :p Okayy... proving is one thing. I ll ask you guys this: wherein here is the trouble. Which step did we make the mistake at, so we get such erratic answers that would cause Newton to suffer a heart attack if he ever saw this? ;)

OpenStudy (anonymous):

@apoorvk smart reply. Newton would have given us gifts!!!!!

OpenStudy (apoorvk):

oh yeah @foolformath already asked this. so where is the error, aadarsh can you think? (this question was presented in Bansal classes entrance test multiple times)

OpenStudy (lgbasallote):

@Callisto how do you tag @FoolForMath with ffm???

OpenStudy (apoorvk):

like this @ffm

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Really? Bansal people are copying from Brain Mapping Academy, Hyderabad.

OpenStudy (apoorvk):

:D sorry for the troubles FFM

OpenStudy (lgbasallote):

i dont think @ffm is the same as @FoolForMath yes?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

I am not notified with @ffm

OpenStudy (apoorvk):

may be, aadarsh. or the other way around. someone always copies from somebody

OpenStudy (anonymous):

@Mani_Jha , @AravindG , @payalvsangle , @heena , @sheena101 , @gurvinder , @Ishaan94 , please try. I have to present this before my seniors and get cash prize.

OpenStudy (callisto):

Hmmm... I was trying to show that I was responding his words, so .... it doesn't matter if I have really tagged him :P

OpenStudy (apoorvk):

So, Aadarsh where is the trouble. try guessing!

OpenStudy (anonymous):

@apoorvk bhai, there is no mistake. Mistake der in assumption.

OpenStudy (lgbasallote):

the fallacy works well

OpenStudy (mani_jha):

@As a general rule, you shouldn't multiply or divide an equation by zero.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

let x=0 then 20x = 100x or x = 5x or 1 = 5 (How are you cancelling x? This is division by zero)

OpenStudy (mani_jha):

(1−2)^2=(2−1)^2=1 1−2=2−1 2=4 1=2 Find out the mistake in this.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Mistake is in this: 1-2 = 2-1

OpenStudy (kinggeorge):

How about a proof that shows \(e=1\)? \[\Large e=e^{2\pi i \over 2\pi i}=(e^{2\pi i})^{1 \over 2 \pi i}=1^{1 \over 2 \pi i}=1\]

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Hats off to @KingGeorge .

OpenStudy (mani_jha):

Haha. Good. I used a fallacy to prove another fallacy!

OpenStudy (anonymous):

@King , @shruti , @neha2050 , @salini Please try.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

\(a^2 = b^2 \implies \pm a= \pm b \) So there are two solutions.

OpenStudy (mani_jha):

@KingGeorge, finding the value of anything to a complex power doesn't make sense. You can't be sure that: \[1^{1/2\pi i}=1\]

OpenStudy (kinggeorge):

An alternative proof I found online: Let \(2e=f\). Then \(2^{2 \pi i}e^{2 \pi i} =f^{2\pi i}\). Since \(e^{2\pi i}=1\), we know that \(2^{2\pi i}=f^{2\pi i}\). This means that \(2=f\). From that we substitute \(f\) back in, and get \[2e=2\]Thus, \(e=1\)

OpenStudy (anonymous):

@KingGeorge: When a number is raised to a complex power, the result is not precisely defined.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

See here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_fallacy.

OpenStudy (kinggeorge):

It's the basically the same deal for the second one. \(f^{2\pi i}\) can get really funky. \(2^{2\pi i}\) is already funky.

OpenStudy (apoorvk):

exactly. there is a mistake as @ffm just showed. how do you think are you dividing by '0'??

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Can we not try to prove that division by zero is indeed possible? At least by this, we can get the Abel Prize.

OpenStudy (apoorvk):

Abel prize. lol

OpenStudy (apoorvk):

you 'll get special academic razzies for that!

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Lets hope so!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

OpenStudy (kinggeorge):

@Mani_Jha The actual problem with my original proof is that \[\Large e^{{2 \pi i} \over {2 \pi i}} \neq (e^{2 \pi i})^{1 \over {2 \pi i}}\]Complex exponents don't do that.

OpenStudy (mani_jha):

@Aadarsh, You can't do that. That's why zero is called the 'hero' of Mathematics!

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Oooooo! Really??

OpenStudy (anonymous):

@shruti , @PRINCEOFPERSIA please try.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

tumne apne info mei ye sab kya likh dala hai?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Mera naam hai didi!!!!!! Yeh to maine dhamaal se copy kiya hai.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

OpenStudy (anonymous):

cool...yhi kaam kro aur ye kya qestn post kar rakha hai. i felt sumth imp. is there but is'nt

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Multiply zero on both sides. 1 x 0 = 2 x 0 0 = 0 1 = 2

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Smart answer, Prince Bhai.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Thanks @ Aadarsh..

OpenStudy (experimentx):

1 = 1 1^0 = 2^0 = 3^0 = a^0 1 = 2 = 3 = a

Can't find your answer? Make a FREE account and ask your own questions, OR help others and earn volunteer hours!

Join our real-time social learning platform and learn together with your friends!
Can't find your answer? Make a FREE account and ask your own questions, OR help others and earn volunteer hours!

Join our real-time social learning platform and learn together with your friends!