Ask your own question, for FREE!
English 12 Online
OpenStudy (anonymous):

What is a claim and what is a counter claim someone please help me!!! D:

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

A counter claim is used to counter a previous argument... Say, the first argument claims that we need more state parks, while the counter claim argues that we do not need more state parks.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Don't understand much. :P

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Okay. So there's the first argument, then there's the second argument that is against that, okay?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Can i show you this work i am doing about counter claim and Argument organizer? I want you to take a look

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Yeah

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Sure.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Or want a pic?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

a screenshot works

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Here http://imgur.com/dyU0BAe

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Okay, so what is your first claim?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Well i have to tell if teens should be allowed to play sports?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Not just sports... Dangerous sports. :p

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Well one reason they should play sports is cause they can get hurt

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

So you need evidence to support a claim stating that "yes, teens should be able to play dangerous sports" and a counterclaim saying "no, teens should not be able to play dangerous sports".

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

You need evidence for both.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Oo like the Pros and cons of playing sports?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Yes!! Exactly!

OpenStudy (anonymous):

:D

OpenStudy (anonymous):

SO counterclaim will be the cons and the pros will be the claim?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Yes.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Yeah also it says Source one and source two you have any idea why?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

And whats rebuttal

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

It says source one and two because it wants you to provide evidence of why, so the source is where that evidence came from. And rebuttal is a contradiction.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

ooo ok wait for claim can i put why Why teens should be allowed to play sports And counterclaim i put Why teens shouldn't be able to play sports?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Yes.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

k cool and for reason 1 i right down the reason?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Yep! You got it! ^.^

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Aight! :D How about Evidence/support?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

That's where you'll type supporting evidence to prove why that claim is better.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

So i can type in a website or something?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

no, that's for the source. The evidence is something like "Dr. Sondso tells us that in his studies, teens who played dangerous sports got hurt more than those who did not."

OpenStudy (anonymous):

ooo like i get it from a site?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Yes. Or a book or whatever.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

ok now i put reason 1 Kid should be able to play sports cause there fun and reason 2 i make it from the counter claim?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Yeah.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

aight whats a rebuttal again?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

It's a contradiction. So if reason 1 to the claim was "Kids should be able to play dangerous sports because it is fun", the rebuttal would be "Kids should not be able to play dangerous sports because they could get seriously injured."

OpenStudy (anonymous):

The opposite or something?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Sort of, it's the argument against it.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

k But i can't find a evidence of my claim

OpenStudy (anonymous):

reason*

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Hmm. :/

OpenStudy (anonymous):

:P

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Yeah, that's a problem. :b

OpenStudy (anonymous):

I can't make it up wither right?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

either*

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Probably not. :/

OpenStudy (anonymous):

http://imgur.com/7tDQgFO heres a look at it right now

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Okay, but look closer, it is talking about dangerous sports, not just sports in general.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

oops

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Yeah. That's why it's so much harder.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Do i try now?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

Yeah. I've only got 10 minutes left to be online, but hopefully you'll find something.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

i will thanks! :D

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Wait what will should i put for source one and two?

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

The website links.

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

That you got your evidence from.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

k

OpenStudy (.th3_m0nst3r.):

\(\huge\frak\rlap{\color{black}{\bigstar~Good~Luck!~\bigstar}}{\color{lime}{\; \bigstar~Good~Luck!~\bigstar}}\)

OpenStudy (anonymous):

Thanks

Can't find your answer? Make a FREE account and ask your own questions, OR help others and earn volunteer hours!

Join our real-time social learning platform and learn together with your friends!
Can't find your answer? Make a FREE account and ask your own questions, OR help others and earn volunteer hours!

Join our real-time social learning platform and learn together with your friends!