Which argument is an example of overgeneralization?

Question

anonymous · Answer

My German shepherd bit several family members before I got him a new collar, but has not since then. The new collar must have stopped him from biting.

I want to get a German shepherd as a pet, but my friends say that it is likely to bite me and won't be a good pet. I agree with them.

I was bitten by a German shepherd as a child, so I do not want to get a dog as a pet because it will bite me.

My German shepherd has bitten two people, so I have to send him to the pound or muzzle him.

anonymous · Answer

Is it C or D

skyphos · Answer

I think C since the person was bit once as a child. He or her does not want to get a dog because of that one incident.

skyphos · Answer

Plus the person is saying any kind of dog will bite

skyphos · Answer

*him or her if she gets a pet

solomonzelman · Answer

yes, C is the only correct choice.

solomonzelman · Answer

if someone doesn't know why that is so, we will be happy to address that.... :D

anonymous · Answer

Thanks guys!