Ask your own question, for FREE!
Geography 15 Online
OpenStudy (anonymous):

Can anyone help me?

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

Depends on the question.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

What is the difference between a nation, a state, and a nation-state

OpenStudy (anonymous):

@e.mccormick

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

OK, they used to call them all states. Did you try looking up the terms? Any you find particularly confusing?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

she said we cant look them up, is a nation like the culture and language?, state being were they live?

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

Can't look them up? Hmmm... did the material cober them at all? While nations and states have cultural aspects, think more along the lines of who makes the laws and what those laws deal with at the national and state levels.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

know, she said because it was in a earlier module. but I couldn't find it. and the government?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

they deal with people culture and what they do?

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

It all goes back to the Greeks... well, I can trace it back that far. The Greeks were in several different city-states. Each was its own territory and sovereignty. There was no nation in the way that we see it. Now, they did have Greek pride! Someone attacked Greece and they might get trounced by large groups of the city-states. Eventually a few leaders unified all of Greece. These were some of the early nations. All the people unified under one government. But frankly, that national government was mostly concerned with trade, borders, and threats to the whole nation. They left the day to day stuff up to the local leaders, the city-states. Now, that sound anything like how the USA is today?

OpenStudy (anonymous):

know not to me, I think the government does try's to do everything so they don't leave stuff to local thinkers.

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

Well, look at the constitution. It delegates some power to the national government (tade and problems between states) and leaves the rest to the state governments. The states get to decide what speeds yu drive on what roads, where you can build certain businesses, and so on. So the national level is very different from the state.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

but don't it still have to get passed by some one for it to go through?

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

Well, what last they do and how involved they are in day to day living is very different. I do admit that the US government is poking its nose more and more into personal lives. However, in general, when you get pulled over on the freeway it is a state official, not a federal one. You see county and state buildings all over, but federal ones are only in some locations. State laws are enforced by cities, but federal ones are only enforced by the feds.

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

So, let's work in the premise that a nation and a state are different in how much they meddle in day to day life and what they are overall on top of. Then what would you call it if a government did all of that in one? Say they were both the local and the overall governing body wrapped into one.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

sorry my os was messing up. but nation-state?

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

Yah. And that is essentially it. You have a nation that takes over some things for all the states and sets up the overall laws. Inside the nation you have states with their own control of the people. But if there is only one government and it does both, it is a nation-state.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

oh okay I see.

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

And if you can remember how the USA is structured (Well, on paper) you should be able to remember the terms.

OpenStudy (anonymous):

ookay thank you help and time:)

OpenStudy (anonymous):

*okay

OpenStudy (e.mccormick):

np. Have fun!

Can't find your answer? Make a FREE account and ask your own questions, OR help others and earn volunteer hours!

Join our real-time social learning platform and learn together with your friends!
Can't find your answer? Make a FREE account and ask your own questions, OR help others and earn volunteer hours!

Join our real-time social learning platform and learn together with your friends!