Ask your own question, for FREE!
Language and Culture 12 Online
OpenStudy (13ziar):

can you please tell me why we use different pronouns in different sentences: pourquoi du/ de la / des/ de l' pourquoi un/ une et apres j'aime je mange DE LA salade et une pomme j'aime LA salade

OpenStudy (13ziar):

@RhondaSommer @Photon336 @ace-n-it @imqwerty @Nnesha @Awolflover1 @AloneS @Aveline @asett @Atrineas @Cammie_1D5SOS @DominiRican1013 @emmagrace231 @Elsa213 @DominiRican1013 @haleyelizabeth2017

OpenStudy (13ziar):

if you know french please help me

OpenStudy (asett):

je mange de la salade et une pomme. Here, you are basically saying SOME (de la) salad, whereas in j'aims la salade, you're saying THE (la) salad. Does that make sense?

OpenStudy (13ziar):

yep

OpenStudy (13ziar):

how do you know what to use when

RhondaSommer (rhondasommer):

lol I dont know french but I have a friend who does. I believe that the reasoning is simply that the sentence structure is different, for example: in japanese I would say watashi wa which means "I" But if I say watashi no it means "me" it can specify what you are saying

OpenStudy (13ziar):

ok :-l

OpenStudy (asett):

Just like in English: WAITER: What do you want to eat? ME: I would like to eat SOME salad. [Notice you could also say THE salad in this case] secondly, ME: I like the salad. [Notice that saying "I like some salad" is grammatically incorrect.] When you're talking about something that cannot be numbered, such as salad or water or salt, we say de la, or 'some'. When we are talking about something that cannot be numbered as a WHOLE, such as the salt or the salad, we simple say la, or 'the'. Notice we never say 'the water'. In both French and English, we always say some water or d'eau.

RhondaSommer (rhondasommer):

you use a different word because you are specifying what you are saying. If you asked who liked blue I would not say "I" I would say "me" do you see what I mean

OpenStudy (asett):

Anything else, @13ziar?

OpenStudy (13ziar):

how do I summarise what you told me ^

OpenStudy (13ziar):

@asett

OpenStudy (asett):

The best way to put, that I know of, is the last paragraph in my response, with the exception that it is de l'eau, not d'eau (some water).

OpenStudy (13ziar):

is there a certain rule that needs to be followed

OpenStudy (asett):

Let me look in my textbook. One mo

OpenStudy (13ziar):

thanks

OpenStudy (asett):

Here is what my textbook says: "Partitives (the du/ de la / des/ de l') are used to say that you want some of an item, whereas indefinite (une, un) and definite (le, la, les) are used to say that you want a whole item or several whole items. Tu prends de la pizza? (part of a whole pizza) Tu prends une pizza? (the entire pizza)

OpenStudy (13ziar):

thanks alot

OpenStudy (13ziar):

:)

OpenStudy (asett):

No problem! Tag me if you need anything else. :)

OpenStudy (13ziar):

ok

Can't find your answer? Make a FREE account and ask your own questions, OR help others and earn volunteer hours!

Join our real-time social learning platform and learn together with your friends!
Can't find your answer? Make a FREE account and ask your own questions, OR help others and earn volunteer hours!

Join our real-time social learning platform and learn together with your friends!